Pleasing our overlords at Google

Overlords at GoogleOur overlords at Google don’t like the way the Wine Curmudgeon writes. Nuts to them.

You may have noticed some changes on the blog this summer – a subhead at the top of every post, the annoying way I repeat the name of the wine in some reviews.

I don’t do those things by choice. I do them because our overlords at Google have decided that’s how blog posts should be written, and my search ranking will suffer if I don’t.

I’ve been writing professionally since I was 16 years old, and I’m good at it. Nevertheless, after more than 40 years of writing success – awards, seven books, and earning my living at a profession that doesn’t make that easy – I have to take writing instructions from an algorithm.

But that’s the way the 21st century wine world works on the Internet.

I won’t bore you with a lot of philosophical maundering about what Google as copy editor means for the quality of writing in the Information Age. It’s enough to know that there are other things that I’m supposed to do that I won’t, because they’re silly. If I wanted to write for third-graders, I’d write children’s books.

But I will note an overriding contradiction: Every post I write gets parsed for readability, and my numerous errors are listed so I can correct them. Yet, somehow, every post – no matter how many faux pas I commit, like this phrase between hyphens – gets an excellent rating for “reading ease.” How can I break so many of Google’s rules (this post, in fact, “needs improvement”), but still be easy to read?

Suck on that, our overlords at Google.

More on Google and wine writing:
Google to WC: Maybe you don’t have to drop dead
Seven years of wine writing on the Internet

3 thoughts on “Pleasing our overlords at Google

  • By George Christo -

    “I think I just threw up in my mouth a little.”
    -Not me, but my nom-de-crayon “Sergey Brin”

  • By Howard Watson Argue -

    Dear WC,

    Does Google charge you to write your blog? Why don’t you tell them to go pack sand, if you’re not charged?


    • By Wine Curmudgeon -

      The problem is that Google has a near monopoly on search traffic on the Internet. This means that if I don’t make the blog Google-search friendly, then the blog won’t score well on Gogole’s algorithm and I won’t get as many visitors. So I have to do some of the Google stuff, even though I don’t want to.

Comments are closed.