Critics Challenge 2015

critics challengeThis year, as the Wine Curmudgeon parses wine competitions and tries to understand how they fit into the next generation of the wine business, the Critics Challenge 2015 stands out. It’s one competition that doesn’t treat the judges like college interns, and where each judge isn’t overwhelmed by tasting hundreds of wines.

Plus, the event always attracts top-notch entries. Who knows? Maybe wineries figure there’s an advantage to letting people who judge wine for a living judge it in a competition.

This year was no exception. We did 160 wines over 1 1/2 days, using the event’s unique format to score the wines. Each table of two judges tasted the same wines, gave each a point total corresponding to a silver, gold, or platinum medal, and the wine received the highest of the two medals. Yes, I had to give a score, which is not something I like, but since it’s more about the medal, I have made my peace with it. That each wine is judged by two people adds another level of quality control, and platinum medals are tasted yet again. In addition, the judges write tasting notes for each medal-winning wine.

Besides, given the quality of the wines, who am I to complain? At one point, Michael Franz (one of the leading critics in the country) and I were handing out platinums like they were bronzes at other competitions. Complete results are here, and the highlights included:

* Perhaps the best flight of pinot noir I’ve ever judged, which included three platinums and six golds. The platinums went to ZD Wines, Coomber Family Ranch, and Dutton-Goldfield, and each wine (as well as most of the golds) was fresh and interesting, far removed from the heavy, overwhelming alcohol bombs that are the current critical favorites. The only catch? Each of the wines cost more than $40.

* A platinum for a merlot costing less $15 from Kon Tiki, a Chilean producer, with surprising depth and subtlety for a grocery store merlot. The bad news? It appears to have limited availability. If you can find it, though, buy as much of it as possible.

* A platinum for the nebbilo from Virginia’s Barboursville Vineyard, one of my favorite U.S. producers. Franz and I each gave it a platinum; this is a terroir-driven wine that speaks to the best of winemaking.

* Tremendous value from a couple of flights of $15 and less Chiantis, including platinum for Banfi, Gabbiao, and Castela D’Albola, as well as four golds.

The fine print: The competition pays a $500 honorarium and travel expenses.

2 thoughts on “Critics Challenge 2015

  • By Ray Dietz - Reply

    I finally got around to checking out the results of the Critics Challenge competition. I was a little bit shocked to read that CK Mondavi plonk was awarded four Golds??? And Barefoot wines got some Golds too! Are they really that good? How is it that the CK Mondavi Chardonnay gets a Gold(90 pts) whilst two single vineyard Napa Chardonnays from Sattui Winery(Named Winery of the Year, no less)only get silvers(87 pts). I guess this is why I find it difficult to take wine competitions seriously. Maybe Jeff could shine some light on how this happens.

    • By Wine Curmudgeon - Reply

      That’s how good I am, Ray. I wrote something about this before you even asked about it. This sort of thing happens all the time — https://winecurmudgeon.com/the-two-buck-chuck-gold-medal-fallout/

      Wine competitions are not perfect, and the only people who claim that they are make money off of them. As I wrote, some wines — and Barefoot is the perfect example — taste better than they normally do when you taste them after high alcohol or too tannic or over extracted wines in a group of eight or 10. Their very simplicity is welcoming. My guess, since I didn’t judge the Mondavi, is that it was a simple wine with some fruit in a flight with lots of oaky, heavy wines. So it’s going to taste better by comparison.

      Stuff happens, and the best competitions try to figure out why and make corrections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.